Don’t blame the farmer
Down To Earth · Published 14 November 2026 · Last updated
India's groundwater crisis stems from systemic contradictions in public interventions and individual survival incentives, rather than farmer irrationality, requiring institutional governance over mechanical access.
Key points
- Rishu Garg published The Borewell Paradox: The Rationality of an Irrational Crisis on 14 November 2026, examining groundwater overexploitation across India.
- The book argues that a farmer drilling a borewell is acting rationally to meet immediate survival needs like crop obligations, debt, and family expenses.
- Mechanised drilling has privatised access to shared common pool resources, allowing individual extraction to outpace institutional governance capacity.
- Garg integrates economic theories from Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky, Nassim Nicholas Taleb, and Garrett Hardin to explain collective resource degradation.
- Lined farm ponds in Ahmednagar, Maharashtra, built with government support, prevent water percolation and convert shared aquifer water into private storage.
- Summer conditions expose the contradiction as community wells and handpumps decline while private ponds retain substantial water reserves.
- Water conservation programmes can register success based on aggregate expenditure and structures while the broader ecological system deteriorates.
- Technical competence without institutional understanding, local knowledge, and ethical responsibility produces unintended ecological harm in rural development.
Background
- Historically, indigenous arrangements in India treated water access, sharing, preservation, and recharge as social questions rather than purely engineering challenges.
- The introduction of modern mechanised drilling altered historical relationships by enabling individual farmers to capture groundwater across property boundaries.
- Public programmes and professional interventions historically focused on engineering solutions, dams, and pumps without adequately modifying landscape-level extraction trajectories.
Prelims facts and Mains angle for this issue are in the full SWAदेSH note.
Original report: Down To Earth