Himanshu: The World Bank's poverty estimates have flaws—India should have its own measures of impoverishment
Mint - Opinion · Published 12 November 2026 · Last updated
The absence of an official Indian poverty line and reliance on World Bank estimates risks policy misallocation, necessitating a domestically anchored consumption-based metric.
Key points
- The World Bank released its India Poverty and Equity Brief in October 2026, updating poverty estimates using 2023-24 data following an earlier release in June using 2022-23 figures.
- Government functionaries have increasingly utilized these multilateral estimates to showcase poverty reduction during their tenure, despite them not being official national figures.
- India has historically been a pioneer in poverty measurement through the erstwhile Planning Commission, which historically set official domestic poverty lines.
- India currently lacks an official poverty line because the government junked the Rangarajan committee report.
- The National Statistical Commission approved the 2017-18 Consumption Expenditure Survey, but the government subsequently withdrew it.
- Consumption surveys were restarted as the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey in 2022-23, yet the government has not constituted a committee to set localized poverty lines.
- The World Bank shifted from Consumer Pyramid data used until 2025 to the latest Household Consumption Expenditure Survey statistics, which featured a split-month survey design and altered sampling.
- The World Bank adopted a new real welfare concept that excludes expenditures on durables, furniture, and medical expenses while including free items like food, textbooks, and uniforms.
Background
- India previously relied on official poverty lines set in domestic currency and anchored to basic minimum needs through debates involving the government, experts, and civil society.
- Successive Finance Commissions have historically utilized domestic poverty estimates for fiscal devolution and resource allocations across states for poverty alleviation programs, with most allocations still tied to 2011-12 estimates.
Prelims facts and Mains angle for this issue are in the full SWAदेSH note.
Original report: Mint - Opinion